This entry is part of a series, Questions» Last week I posted about the need to ask questions about our faith in order to grow. Today we’ll take a look at some doubters in the Bible, how Jesus dealt with questions, and what that means for us.

Caravaggio's Thomas
Being a doubter is entirely biblical. Don’t believe me? Here are three notable doubters. The first is King David (Psalms – How long will you leave me? He was always asking God what on earth is going on? ). The next is John the Baptist who when thrown in gaol (Matt 11:2-3) had questions about whether or not Jesus was really the Christ, or if he should await another. The third is Thomas, but we’ll get to him in a moment. In fact, the only ones in the Bible that thought they had it all figured out and were proudly proclaiming the fact were the Pharisees…and look what they ended up doing. They killed the Messiah. Be very wary of anyone who says they have never ever had doubts or questions about their faith. Everyone doubts from time to time.
Back to Thomas.
I think Thomas has been pretty hard done by over the years. How could he possibly doubt the Christ when he was standing right in front of him? I can almost hear you thinking..I bet you would never make the same mistake. Don’t worry you’re not the only one…don’t be a doubting Thomas…why worry when you can pray, right?
If you haven’t heard about Thomas, you can read about him HERE . He very famously said “Nope! I’m not going to believe it is really the risen Jesus until I can stick my fingers in those holes.” It wasn’t as if he was a non-believer, he was called by Jesus and had walked with him for the past three years. They had served alongside one another! And yet, he asked the question.
Thomas had questions and he pursued the answers. He poked and prodded (literally) until he was satisfied with the answers he was getting. He walked away stronger for it.
Was Jesus angry? Absolutely not! He didn’t push Thomas aside or embarrass him or give him a hard time for his perceived lack of faith. Jesus loved Thomas and showed grace and mercy. He gave him exactly what he needed in order to dispel his doubts. He invited him to come close and touch and see, to explore. God will treat you the same, with patient understanding. God won’t give you what you want to prove your faith. He will give you exactly what you need in order to prove your faith.
Thomas is an example for us in how to tackle the questions when they come up. He wasn’t afraid to go directly to the object of his questions for answers, we shouldn’t be either. He wasn’t going to take someone else’s word for it when he could ask Jesus himself what the deal was. We have the same opportunity. God would much rather we were honest. He sees it anyway.
Before that moment Thomas believed *in* Jesus (he had knowledge about the man), now he believed Jesus, he had taken the next step. He chose to trust him, to believe him, to allow that interaction to fuel his next action, which historians believe included missionary work in what is now India.
Sometimes the journey isn’t as immediate as it was for Thomas.
I’m close to a guy like Thomas. He is a highly intelligent guy who asks questions like -
If God is powerful and true who reveals himself, why are there so many denominations all believing different things, shouldn’t we all be believing the same thing?
If there really is a God, why doesn’t he speak directly and audibly to me and tell me what he wants?
Why would a loving God kill someone for working on the sabbath?
How could Noah’s ark possibly be a true story, and why are there ancient manuscripts of a flood story that predate biblical manuscripts?
Why does God seemingly answer car park prayers and not cure cancer or heal amputees?
Why did he let my Christian uncle die young and leave four young kids?
He sought answers for years and was met with everything from outright laughs, to “you just have to accept it on faith”, to people trying to fix his lack of faith. All of this coupled with a grab bag of experiences observing Christians has brought him to a point in his life where he is unable to reconcile the religious life with what he has come to believe is true about God from a rational standpoint, sifting through all of the things he has experienced and learned about in life. He left the church some time ago, and now considers himself a deist .
I can totally see his point. I can understand how he has arrived at this view of the world, and I can empathise with the experiences he’s had. But I don’t agree with his conclusions.
My major problem though, is that for the most part, I am completely unable to answer his questions, nor provide what he might consider to be a rational explanation for my belief. Even my first-hand experience is considered subjective and unreliable since it cannot be repeated nor proven. I’m fine with that. From my perspective, I know that it is not my job to defend God. That was never part of the job description. I need to be able to give an answer relating to why I believe, and I am required to love. So that’s what I do. I trust God to take care of the rest. He is happy for me to pray for him, and asks me to do so….so I do. A lot.
It’s not an easy place for me to be in, but I have to say that it has probably been the single most strengthening thing I’ve been through. And probably the best thing for my faith. I have had to think about exactly what I believe, and why. I have had to start exploring deeper and relying more heavily on God to guide me and encourage me.
Have I questioned the legitimacy and foundations of my faith? Of course. A well put, compelling argument that appears to make sense will, of course, make you think.
Have I thought about chucking in the towel?
Yup.
Some days it all seems like too much hard work.
So why do I keep going?
In my life I’ve experienced enough of God to be able to trust that what I don’t understand at this point is either discoverable, will be revealed at some point when I need to know, or I really don’t need to know. Just like Thomas, God has provided me with what I need to be able to trust at this point in time.
It’s about making a choice. You either trust God or you don’t. If you come to the conclusion that you can’t trust God…kill off your “faith” once and for all. Living with a foot in either camp “just in case” is deplorable to God (Revelations speaks of those who are lukewarm being spewed up and the Gospels talk of the impossibility of serving both God and Mammon). If you decide that you know enough about God for you to trust him, then jump in with both feet even if you don’t have all the answers and continue on with the life-long research project that is God.
I pray that if you are looking for answers that God would give you exactly what you need to allow you to trust and move forward when the time is right.
Are you at a point where you aren’t sure if you can trust? Can I pray for you?