This entry is part of a series, Questions» So far we’ve talked about being honest with ourselves about the questions that pop up about our faith, and we’ve looked at some strategies for dealing with our own questions in a constructive way. Now we turn to thinking about how to deal with other people who ask us curly questions.

Depending on the crowd you run with, you might get genuine curly questions seeking genuine answers, or you might get the type of question that is designed to wind you up and make you look like a fool.
If you work in knowledge work like I do, it will more likely than not be the latter, with a sprinkling for the former for a little light relief. Both are hard work! Either way, to make any progress it comes down to a matter of needing to build trust in a world heavily flavoured with skepticism and distrust.
Many people see Christianity (and religion in general) as an ideology that has been used for centuries to control people, and they rail against the indoctrination that they see around them or that they themselves received as children. They’ve been fed a steady media diet of Ned Flanders style fanaticism or crackpot Christian fundamentalists spewing hate as they demonstrate for their cause, and generally have a very poor opinion of Christians. In fact, great numbers of people have have come to the conclusion that God and religion are destructive simply by interacting with Christians. We know that not all Christians are the same, and we know that God cannot be judged conclusively by looking at the church alone (although theologically speaking that is one of the measures of a healthy church — presenting an accurate reflection of the attributes of God. How’s yours doing by the way? Try asking the community, you can’t always tell from the inside.).
There are a lot of people carrying religious scars out there, and we have our work cut out for us to find a footing for any sort of credible discussion about a loving, compassionate God.
Good thing we have the perfect tool that no other religion or philosophy has in their toolbox. Grace.
We need to create an atmosphere that is safe for people to talk, to ask questions without fear of judgement and dogma being rained down on them. Seemingly hostile people will stick around and keep exploring their questions if they feel safe and accepted, and sooner or later they will let their guard down enough to find God. Through God’s grace it’s our job to provide that safe space where you can dialogue and wrestle with the questions together.
Here are ten things I like to keep in mind when I’m talking to people about God stuff:
- Listen, listen, listen — I very nearly had this one as the solitary point in this post. LISTEN…don’t sit there thinking about your next argument. REALLY LISTEN. Cannot emphasise this one enough.
- Don’t make assumptions — No two people have the same story in life, don’t assume that you understand where someone is simply because you’ve heard a similar story.
- Ask more questions than you give answers — Ask “why?” What is the story behind the question? Dig deeper. And remember, if you don’t have the answer…say so! Don’t pretend and waffle! Find the answer together if you need to. If you are in over your head, get help
- Do not judge, and never ever say that the way someone is thinking is “wrong”… what is wrong? They think you think “wrong” too…I wouldn’t mind betting that they think that for you to believe in God is much the same as believing in the Tooth Fairy. Share your story, be open and honest about your faith. Remember that you need God’s grace just as much as they do.
- R.E.S.P.E.C.T. — Respect is essential. Value them as a person and DO NOT view them as a project (i.e. your chief goal is to get them thinking the same way you do). Build a relationship without an agenda. Remember that it is not your job to change this person, that’s the role of the Holy Spirit.
- NO jargon…using churchy language immediately signals that Christianity (and the church) is an exclusive club that only the in-crowd know how to interpret. The message of the gospel is simple at it’s core. Don’t complicate it with words that need interpretting and that will create a barrier. Of course some conversations will go deeper, be sure to interpret theological words for your listener. Church/religious/faith culture is like stepping into an alien land for many people; if you want to know how that feels, go visit your local mosque or temple and sit through a service.
- Knowing your Bible inside and out is not enough. It’s not a magic book. Of course it is the foundation for believers, but there are a great many people who reject the Bible outright. For these people, it is nothing more than a collection of fairy stories that may or may not have some historical basis. For this reason you will have times where you are completely unable to use the Bible as a reference for truth in the short term. Some understanding of how the Bible came about, why it is an authoritative source for Christians and how we are to interpret the myriads of different literary styles within its covers may be necessary. More importantly people are going to be looking very closely at your life to see that what you talk about is true and that it works. They will watch closely how you treat people…does this Bible stuff really work in real life?
- Let them walk away — be willing to let them walk away. Give them time to process and explore in peace. Understand that God works behind the scenes and that God’s timing and their timing is not your timing. Want to be a part of the continuing story in that person’s life? Pray.
- Encourage — affirm and recognise the steps they take towards seeking God. Acknowledge God’s work in their lives over time as you see their thought patterns change over time.
- Challenge — Only when the time is right…when you’ve built trust and a genuine relationship…only then have you earned the right to challenge and to ask some tough questions of your own. Never ever go in with the hellfire and brimstone approach trying to scare them into believing in God…that’s more likely than not one of the things that turned them off in the first place. Intolerance and religious arrogance is at loggerheads with today’s culture…to be blunt, it is at loggerheads with the gospel. Grace is the key word here.
A warning
Some people firing questions at you are not going to be happy unless they get you cranky…do not get defensive. It may feel like a personal attack, but it’s not most of the time. If the person is getting wound up and upset, take a breather, ask, “you are obviously very passionate about this, can you help me understand why?” Steer conversation back to them and listen carefully. If the discussion gets past the point of no return in the crankiness stakes, suggest you continue the discussion at a later date when things have calmed down. Anger is never productive. Then remember to get back to the conversation!
Resources
Here are a couple of resources that you may find helpful.
Encouragement for you
As you jump in boots and all, don’t be afraid of exploring alternative beliefs to yours, be they other Christian doctrines or entirely different religious systems or worldviews. Engaging in this type of critical thinking about what you believe is not only good for strengthening your convictions and thought processes, it helps others to see that you are not a shallow religious bigot, that you are capable of understanding other view points, and as such you create for yourself a toehold for being able to show God’s grace.
Do you have any tips to share?